In an era where student debt is ballooning and access to higher education remains uneven, North Carolina’s NC Promise Tuition Plan stands out as a rare policy success. Implemented in 2018, the plan reduces tuition at four public universities to just $500 per semester for in-state students. The move has been applauded across the political spectrum as a practical approach to boosting college access and supporting economically disadvantaged students.
But beneath the celebration lies a deeper conversation—particularly among advocates for racial justice—about whether reduced tuition is a sufficient response to a history in which Black Americans were systematically and often violently denied education.
NC Promise is, in many ways, a model for affordable education policy. It is also a window into the ongoing debate over what true educational equity means, especially for the descendants of enslaved Africans whose access to literacy and learning was once not just restricted—but criminalized.
What Is NC Promise?
Launched by the North Carolina General Assembly and implemented by the UNC System in fall 2018, the NC Promise Tuition Plan dramatically reduces the cost of attending four state universities:
- Fayetteville State University (FSU) – Historically Black College & University (HBCU)
- Elizabeth City State University (ECSU) – HBCU
- University of North Carolina at Pembroke (UNCP) – Serves a large Native American and rural student population
- Western Carolina University (WCU) – Regional comprehensive university in western North Carolina
Under NC Promise:
- In-state students pay $500 per semester in tuition.
- Out-of-state students pay $2,500 per semester.
These tuition rates apply universally to undergraduates, regardless of income or academic performance. The program is state-subsidized, meaning the universities are reimbursed by the state to cover the difference in lost tuition revenue.
The goal? To make college more affordable, increase enrollment, and strengthen regional campuses, particularly those that serve underserved communities.
Positive Outcomes and Policy Impact
The NC Promise Tuition Plan has had a number of measurable effects across its participating universities:
1. Increased Enrollment
Since its implementation, all four NC Promise schools have reported enrollment growth, reversing trends of declining admissions, especially at the smaller HBCUs. For example:
- Elizabeth City State University saw its first enrollment increase in nearly a decade.
- Fayetteville State University experienced a rise in transfer and adult learners who were previously priced out of higher education.
2. Reduced Student Debt
By drastically cutting the cost of tuition, NC Promise reduces reliance on student loans. This is particularly significant for Black students, who, according to the Education Data Initiative, graduate with an average of $25,000 more in student debt than their white peers. NC Promise helps lower the long-term economic burden of college on these students and their families.
3. Economic Revitalization of Local Communities
By driving enrollment and reducing financial strain on students, the program also has broader economic effects—revitalizing local economies surrounding the universities, increasing workforce development, and making college a feasible option for first-generation and nontraditional students.
Historical Context: Black Americans and the Denial of Education
While NC Promise offers real relief, it also prompts necessary reflection on the historical denial of education to Black Americans—a wound that reduced tuition alone cannot fully heal.
Enslavement and Literacy Bans
During slavery, literacy was seen as dangerous. Southern states passed laws criminalizing the education of enslaved people. In some places, teaching a Black person to read or write was punishable by fines, imprisonment, or violence. For Black people themselves, the punishment was often far worse—beatings, mutilation, or death.
Post-Emancipation Struggles
After the Civil War, freedmen established schools under threat of violence. Black educators and students were often attacked, lynched, or driven out. In the Jim Crow era, Black schools were consistently underfunded, lacked basic resources, and were excluded from public investment.
Systemic Exclusion in Higher Education
Throughout the 20th century, Black students faced segregated institutions, discriminatory admissions practices, and a curriculum that marginalized or erased Black history and scholarship. Even today, disparities in college access, graduation rates, and faculty representation persist.
Equity vs. Reparative Justice
While NC Promise effectively reduces the cost of college for all students, critics argue that it stops short of addressing the structural and intergenerational inequities that have long defined Black Americans’ relationship to higher education.
A Universal Policy with Uneven Impact
Although the program benefits everyone, it does not specifically target the communities most harmed by past exclusion. Some advocates argue that descendants of enslaved Africans in the U.S.—known as Foundational Black Americans—should receive tuition-free college as a form of reparative justice. They note that while universal policies can provide relief, only targeted reparations can repair harm.
The Case for Debt-Free Black Education
Given the history of being barred from education, advocates argue that public college should be free for Foundational Black Americans, with additional investment in Historically Black Colleges and Universities (HBCUs), culturally responsive curricula, and guaranteed economic pathways after graduation.
A Model for the Nation?
Despite its limitations, NC Promise is a model of what practical, scalable tuition reform can look like. It is transparent, well-funded, and broadly accessible. More importantly, it has demonstrated that states can make higher education affordable without requiring new bureaucracies or complicated applications.
Several states—including New Mexico and New York—have launched similar initiatives, but NC Promise’s focus on regional and minority-serving institutions gives it a unique, equity-driven character.
If replicated and expanded—with room for race-conscious, reparative elements—programs like NC Promise could reshape the national conversation on college access and affordability.
Conclusion
The NC Promise Tuition Plan is an example of how state policy can positively impact students, communities, and historically underfunded institutions. It offers a roadmap for increasing access to higher education in a way that is both economically sound and socially beneficial.
However, for many, it also highlights what is still missing: a direct response to the centuries-long exclusion of Black Americans from education systems they helped build, fund, and sustain—often without pay or recognition.
As states look to expand similar initiatives, NC Promise should be viewed as both a success story and a starting point—one that opens the door to bigger conversations about reparations, racial justice, and the true meaning of educational equity in America.
Discover more from BLKsignal News
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
